Buoyed by their 1950 League Cup success earlier in the season, Motherwell wasted no time in plotting a course back to the national stadium in the Scottish Cup. Peterhead, Hamilton and Ayr Utd (after a replay) were beaten in the early rounds of the 1951 Scottish Cup to set up a fourth game of the season against Hibernian.
The Hibees of course were the losers when ‘Well triumphed in the League Cup Final and were afforded an opportunity for revenge in the capital with 46,000 cramming into Tynecastle to witness an exciting semi-final. Kelly gave ‘Well an early lead before Hibs were reduced to ten-men through injury. They battled back to level before Kelly restored Motherwell’s lead before the interval. McLeod made it 3-1 to ‘Well before the Leith outfit reduced the deficit once more. It wasn’t to be however, and Motherwell were in their second cup final of the season.
More than 131,000 made it to Hampden as ‘Well sought to secure a momentous Cup double but it wasn’t to be as, not for the first time, or indeed the last, Celtic edged out the Steelmen in the Final.
Happily the Scottish Cup success that supporters of the Steelmen craved would not be long in coming with the old trophy finally wrapped in claret and amber ribbons in April 1952.
Forfar, St Mirren, Dunfermline (after a replay) and Rangers (also after a replay) in the match that attracted Fir Park’s largest ever attendance were beaten as Motherwell made it to the semi final. Hearts would be Motherwell’s opposition in an arduous contest that stretched over three games and was witnessed by a mind-boggling 238,000 spectators.
The first encounter saw ‘Well come from behind to draw 1-1 with Watson netting. In the replay, the roles would be reversed with the Gorgie side requiring to equalise Watson’s opener to retain their place in the competition, with not an even another thirty minutes of extra-time able to separate the sides.
Incredibly the teams were required to lock horns for a third time just two days later when to the great delight of the Fir Park faithful Motherwell were able to strike a telling blow. Goals from Kelly and Humphries appeared to put Stevenson’s men on the cusp of another final place but the capital outfit fought back doggedly with a goal to stay in the tie. Their luck was to be out however with Redpath’s last minute strike taking ‘Well through to the final.
Ten days later and Motherwell would be back at Hampden where they triumphed, beating Dundee 4-0 in front of more than 136,000 fans, and avenging a humiliating 5-1 League semi-final defeat from earlier in the season that had ended Motherwell’s hopes of retaining the League Cup.
Although Motherwell’s league form had been somewhat up and down in the early fifties there was no question the Steelmen were a terrific cup team and only a semi-final replay loss to Celtic in 1954 prevented the Fir Park side making another Hampden final.
The following season would see that rectified however as Motherwell made it to the 1954 League Cup Final. Escaping from a group containing St Mirren, Kilmarnock and Raith Rovers, Rangers were beaten over two-legs to set up a tie with the League Cup holders East Fife.
The Fifers took the lead at Hampden after just three minutes but the Steelmen would fight back and a double from Bain saw them into the Final. Unfortunately by the time the Final came around Motherwell found themselves with something of an injury crisis to contend with and were far from at full strength as they went down 4-2 to Hearts.
For the best part of the next three decades, semi-finals would prove to be tough going for those of a claret and amber persuasion with loss after loss leading supporters to wonder if their favourites would ever make a Hampden final again!
St Mirren (League Cup 1955), Clyde (Scottish Cup 1958), Rangers (Scottish Cup 1962), Celtic (Scottish Cup 1965), St Johnstone (League Cup 1969), Airdrie (Scottish Cup 1975), Rangers (Scottish Cup 1976), Celtic (Scottish Cup 1985), Celtic (League Cup 1986), Rangers (League Cup 1987) would all put the Steelmen to the sword in varying fashions. From questionable refereeing, to plucky losses, to Hampden’s square goal-posts – it appeared no matter the circumstances it seemed things just wouldn’t fall Motherwell’s way.
Even newly established tournaments such as the Texaco Cup would bring heartbreak when ‘Well lost out to Hearts in the last four in 1971.
Suddenly, in the early nineties, things dramatically changed for the better…